Community Header
< BACK TO ALL CONVERSATIONS

A Mothering Dilemma

Started by won 1/25/2012 12:34:11 PM

I have a son in ninth grade. He begged me to allow him to take AP classes in both Geometry and Biology at the end of last school year. I told him clearly that I would support him in that, but if I found him not giving 100% and then not succeeding, I'd support him in ways he might not like (making him sit at his desk and do work, missing social activities, etc.). It was an issue because his then math teacher was on the fence about if she felt he could handle the more advanced math - not because of learning but because he doesn't do his homework and a class like that demands it. 

 

So we're done with first semester. He had missing assignments all over the place! But got a 96% on his exam. So clearly he is smart enough. He just lacks responsibility and follow through.

Now he wants my blessing to drop the class and go down to regular geometry instead of advanced. I don't know what to do. I don't want him to feel like he couldn't cut it -that could wind up being a blow to his esteem. I don't want him to think I didn't mean what I said about supporting him in ways he might not like. But I also don't want him to be miserable. I'd like to see him buckle down and do all his homework and finish what he started - but is worth the possible risk of alienation? I want him to be able to share things with me throughout high school...and this has me stumped. 

Input welcome. 

Share Conversation

Embed
+ Login to choose updates by email

Replies


Viewing 1 - 4 of 4
We haven't had to go down that road quite yet. Well, not in those terms. However, when my young son wanted to quit an activity that he had chosen to do, I told him he made the decision and that he had to stick it out until the end. After that, he wouldn't have to do it any longer if he so desired. My husband and I have talked about this at length and we have both decided that all of our children will finish what they start unless there is a serious threat to their health (severe injury, sickness, etc.). We want them to learn that they have to live with and make the best with their mistakes and choices. We don't want them to learn to be quitters or that mom and dad will always bail them out. Of course, within reason. If I were in your position, I think (no matter how hard it would be to see my kid get bad grades and suffer - trust me, I am one of those that was SUPER competitive in school and get woozy just thinking of my child getting a bad grade) I would tell him to complete the year. Learn how to study and work hard and do what you set out to accomplish in the first place. After all, you did give him fair warning the year prior.

""

Reply by Chelsey

1/25/2012 6:49:01 PM

I took AP classes in high school, and I agree they're tough, but they're meant to be. He may not like it, but if I were you, I would make him see it through. Those classes are advanced to better prepare him for college. He can obviously do the work, so maybe he needs the class just to teach him to get the work done. If he makes a lower grade, so be it. I think it's more admirable to admissions counselors to see him push himself and do a little worse than to see him breeze by in classes that don't test his abilities. 


""

Reply by won

1/26/2012 1:29:16 PM

Thank you both. I absolutely agree with what you both said, at first look. Those were my feelings and to be honest, still are to a great extent. As of 5pm yesterday, I was definitely leaning heavily towards no being the answer.

Then my son had his weekly therapy session and I went in this week with him so we could process this question together (son is dx as ODD and depression). The therapist brought up a valid point that in college, students are able to and do drop classes. Therapist also felt that for me to not grant this request could cause quite a problem with lack of cooperation in the immediate future. 

We are also dealing with a separate issue as a family which is going to be a serious matter for my son to come to terms accepting in the near future...so after much thought, I've chosen to let him drop the class. The idea is that son 'get his way' this time, because soon on a bigger matter he is not going to - and this can be used as a reminder that sometimes you get what you want, and sometimes you don't.  *I don't feel 100% good about the decision, but honestly I don't think I would have felt 100% about either decision.


""

Reply by Sari

1/26/2012 3:22:23 PM

It sounds like you made the best decision for your family - I hope it goes well for everyone involved!


Reply to Conversation


-OR-

Join & Reply Switch to the simple version
Please review the rules of this community before posting:

Keep it nice and family-friendly please!



< BACK TO ALL CONVERSATIONS