You can also do the Pilgrim hats with a mini peanut butter cup~ that might be easier.
Instructions Here: Pilgrim Hat Cookies
Another idea would be apple turkeys. There are lots of ideas for doing these. I just did a google image search and found lots of variations. They are pretty self explanatory to make, but here are a couple pics: You can use any small items for the tail~ marshmallows, raisins, gumdrops, grapes, cereal (Cheerios or Fruit Loops type), gummy candies, fruit snacks etc...