Community Header
< BACK TO ALL CONVERSATIONS

Natural vs. Epidural Births

Started by Serena , author of Ich liess mein Herz in Deutschland 1/4/2010 12:54:19 PM
I saw we had a thread on birthing stories, I thought I would add this. I know it is a touchy subject, but lets just share experiences, without getting into the heated debate aspect :)
 
I have not yet had kids, but to say that childbirth didn't scare the crap out of me would be a lie. But I have heard so many opinions one way or the other. 
 
I was just curious what was your decision and how did it work out for you?

Share Conversation

Embed
+ Login to choose updates by email

Replies


Viewing 1 - 10 of 18

Reply by Angie

author of The Crew 1/5/2010 12:59:50 PM

So badly wanted and planned for natural births.  My children unfortunately have to be forced out and I was induced each time.  My first I got the epidural because I was having pitocin and natural contractions sepeerate from each other and no break, this allowed me to relax enough for my cervix to open and after 2 hours of pushing my first was 9lbs. 1oz.  My second was induced differently and in essence torpedoed out of my body thus epi not nessecary, 7lb 11oz.  My last child I made it as far as I could naturally but as soon as they decided that I needed pitocin I asked for the epi first.  After all was said and done he was 11lbs. 1 oz.

I say plan for what you in your heart want or know you can handle and be open to changes as these little ones begin calling the shots.


I chose a natural birth for my son and was really happy that I did.  Luckily, we live in the Boulder, CO area and the hospitals there are great about supporting birth plans and natural births. I didn't want an epidural and I even requested that it not be offered. If I wanted it, I knew I could ask for it.  We also asked that it be completely silent at the moment of birth so that my son's father could be the first voice he heard.  The honored that and many other requests. 

We are lucky to live in an age where there are many options for safe births and choices.  Childbirth is something our bodies were made for and it knows what to do - assisted or not.  I agree with Angie - do whatever feels right to you, make sure your voice is heard, and know that you'll do just fine.

Reply by Cop Mama

author of Cop Mama 1/5/2010 6:15:03 PM

I totally agree with Holly. I too had natural births with both my boys. But all along the way, from the very first prenatal check up where they tried to give me the flu shot, I had to fight for mine and my baby's rights.

Serena, the best advice I can give is to do your research and figure out what feels right for you. My DH and I went to Bradley birthing classes. This really helped us to understand the birthing process and what to expect.


Reply by monica

author of Pixel Perfect 1/5/2010 9:54:07 PM
What a great discussion! I went into labor thinking that I am ok with an epidural. I too was induced and contractions are brought on hard with pitocin! My doctor would not let me walk around. I was strapped to my bed by internal monitors, external monitors and a blood pressure cuff. I felt trapped. The only position I could be in was on my back and that's NOT comfortable at all in labor. After 6 hours of no medication and not being able to find natural relief I asked for an epidural. I was able to relax...kinda of through the uncontrollable shaking. But at least I wasn't in pain. But I applaud any woman that can do it naturally!!

Reply by Jess

author of Keep it Together 1/6/2010 8:15:39 PM
I wanted to try natural birth without meds with my first birth, but didn't really have a game plan or was prepared. After 21 hours of labor, I cried for the epidural when I found out I was only 6 cm. Right after, I went through transition and she was born! Now I wish someone had said, "6 cm? You are almost there! " I was thinking it was going to be 21 more hours!!

With my second pregnancy, I was prepared for a natural birth. I read the Bradley book (my dh wasn't on board for taking classes), took pre-natal yoga and learned deep breathing, and had a doula. I still had a 24 hour labor, but it was MUCH easier without the fear that I had during my daughter's labor. Transition wasn't fun, but it was short and he came out pretty fast once I was 8 cm. Honestly, the contractions weren't that bad and very manageable.

If I have another, I'll do natural again :)

Reply by monica

author of Pixel Perfect 1/6/2010 9:01:36 PM
Jess did you love having a doula?? I wanted one with little man but waited till the last minute. I definitely want one the next time!

Reply by Ginger

author of Seven Gifts From Heaven 1/7/2010 1:49:38 AM
Serena,
I agree that its great to have a plan, but you have to be flexible.  Sometimes the plan works out and sometimes it doesn't.  I have 7 children and no epidurals. People think I'm crazy or a really strong person, but honestly I always struggled with all kinds of fear.  I did a lot of reading and decided it was best for me, the baby and my labor to not interfere.  With 7 different births, I could tell you story after story of how obstacles were overcome using natural remedies and how nice it was to labor in my home, at my pace and how I wanted.  Each birth was unique and there were moments of concern, but my midwives are trustworthy, capable women that I trust completely.  My experiences were wonderful with the exception of one birth.  And that one wasn't too bad, just kind of weird (with a different mid-wife).  By the way, and I hope this statement doesn't offend anyone because it was just my personal observation, but the reason I decided to pursue homebirth was because I listened to birth stories and I found a common thread...most hospital births sounded like horror stories and all the home birth stories sounded like heaven on earth.  The hospital stories didn't mean to sound  like horror stories, they usually said they had a great experience and proceeded to tell me how their labor was "managed" by the hospital staff.  But the homebirth stories sounded truly wonderful.  
 
I have a friend who used my mid-wife and allowed me to come to her birth.  I noticed that her labor was very different from mine and she was never in pain like I had been.  My mid-wife was wonderful through it all and eventually had to tell the couple that they weren't going to have a homebirth.  The baby just wasn't going to come naturally and they tried everything!  My friend was taken to a hospital and they gave her an epidural, but that baby just couldn't get out naturally, so she had to have a C section.  It was a disappointment for my friend, but everyone agreed that a healthy baby and mommy was always the most important goal.

Thanks guys so much for all the replies.
 
A bit of info about birth in Germany. Each women is assigned a mid wife, you get to choose them and they work with you six week, pre birth, birthing process, and after bringing baby home. 
 
I have never heard of in home births here, I have heard of natural birthing centers though as an alternative to a hospital. 
 
We are currently in the process of trying to conceive, but pregnancy in itself is a very emotional concept. I go from being 100% for it, too being scared to death, fearing change, and then when finding out I am not yet pregnant feeling disappointment. 
 
I have looked into finding books on pregnancy and preparing for pregnancy, but I have had no luck. The last book I bought was all about asking if you would be a good parent and trying to help people accept that they were just not meant for parenthood, not at all what I was looking for. Do you guys have any recommended books that helped you?
 
I am past the point of deciding if children are right for me, we made that decision, I am looking more for emotional and physical preparation, as well as just general knowledge about the process. 

Reply by Ginger

author of Seven Gifts From Heaven 1/8/2010 12:11:52 AM
I worried all day about how it sounded when I said in my previous post that so many hospital births sounded like horror stories.  I just want to clarify that it was at that particular time in my life all the stories sounded like horror stories.  I was there for all my sister's births (4 kids) at hospitals and I never thought any of her experiences came close to being a horror story.  I think my perception changed while I was pregnant and after reading certain books.  Before I got pregnant I thought women who had natural births were crazy.  But that was before I considered how modern medicine might effect the outcome of the birth.  For my sister, it didn't make much of a difference! 
 
Also, (just a little side note) I ordered a book about home birth right after we found out I was pregnant. I was interested in home birth but my husband didn't like the idea at all.  I dismissed the thought of having one.  Then the book came in and I bought it, brought it home and just left it lying around because I was too discouraged to read it.  My husband picked it up and after reading it he was convinced we should try to have a home birth! :)
 
I completely understand where you're coming from where you feel 100% ready and then scared to death, and then disappointed when you find out you aren't.  We tried to conceive for a total of a year and 8 months and I experienced those exact emotions.   
 
Its wonderful that you want children.  I don't know of any books just off the top of my head, but you've come to the right place.  I think Monica is a good resource for finding the information you're looking for.

Reply by Nicki

author of 400 Things 1/8/2010 9:35:19 AM
I had all four of my children at home, completely natural. Childbirth is not necessarily easy, but don't be afraid; it is what we were created to do! Since I had no previous experience in a hospital, I just made up my mind that this is how I would do it. Every birth went well, some were long, some were very short! Yay! But even after 4, I would not choose a hospital birth (even a natural one) unless there was an actual medical emergency. My sister had 5 at home and then her 6th in a hospital, and it was natural for a hospital, but sooooo different from home. It was high-stress, impersonal, and she actually had very little involvement in the process. At home it's so much different. I realize that there are situations where it's just not an option, but for most people, I highly recommend it!

Reply to Conversation


-OR-

Join & Reply Switch to the simple version
Please review the rules of this community before posting:

Rules are simple. Due to our different upbringings, experiences and beliefs we will have different opinions. I ask that we show respect for those differing opinions. Other than that be open, honest and have fun!

Your reply has been posted!

Edit Reply Jump to Reply Reply Again


< BACK TO ALL CONVERSATIONS